Monday, March 5, 2007

By Julee B.

In life we all have struggles and obstacles that make us who we are. In the novella The Old Man and the Sea, Santiago, the old man, struggles with catching a giant, 18-foot, marlin. Throughout this story Santiago struggles with a cramped hand, being alone and having sharks attack his boat. All of these struggles affect Santiago internally and externally, and shape the plot of this story.


When catching the fish the Old Man hurt his hand severely. “He could feel the steady hard pull of the line and his left hand was cramped” (Pg 58). The old man unfortunately, didn’t have a fishing pole or rod, so he had to hold the line with his hand. While catching the marlin he had to hold it there for a while so his hand became cramped. While also pulling and tugging on the line he cut his hands. He had a tight, secure grip on the line, which made it rub up and down his hands causing his hands to bleed. This made it difficult for the old man to pull on the line to get the marlin up onto the boat. With his hands also being all cut up and bloody it was hard for him to lift the marlin because it was 18-feet.


Another struggle that he has is being alone. “ I wish the boy were here and that I had some salt”. (Pg 56). This quote explains that the old man has no one to help him out, therefore he has to catch the fish all alone. Seeing as the man is old it is also a struggle for him. I think if the boy had gone with him on his fishing trip would have been a lot more successful because he would have had somebody to help him out. I think that the old man internally felt sad. He was out on this huge ocean with no one else with him. The old man didn’t have much back on land either though, so maybe being out on the ocean was like a paradise for him.


One last struggle the old man really has is when the sharks attack his boat. Once the old man gets the marlin, it turns out to be huge, 18 feet long. This is two feet longer than the actual boat. To be able to hold on to the marlin he has to put some of it into the water. Since sharks are attracted to the scent of blood, they came towards the old mans boat where the marlin was. “The shark swung over and the old man saw his eye was not alive and then he swung over once again, wrapping himself in two loops of the rope. (Pg 102). This explains one of the sharks that came up which was a mako. The mako dug its teeth into the side of the marlin, and ended up taking 40 pounds of fresh nice meat. The old man stabs the shark with a harpoon and the shark ends up sinking taking the harpoon with him. Two shovel-nosed sharks then come smelling the stronger scent from the marlin from the other shark. The two sharks took a quarter of the best part of the meat but the Old man ends up killing them both with a knife. Later on another shovel – nosed shark comes and attacks the boat. The old man kills it but the shark takes the knife with him. The last pack of sharks comes taking the rest of the meat.


Santiago, the old man, had many struggles and obstacles throughout this book just like all of us do in life. He shows us that no matter what you should try. Santiago is there for hours and hours struggling to get that one marlin up. He doesn’t give up even though his hands are bloody, cramped and he has no one to help him. I think Ernest Hemingway was trying to show us that you shouldn’t give up and that even if you don’t achieve in the end you will feel proud or someone else will be proud of you.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

yo julee its mike.
i enjoed reading your story, the thesis was very well thought out and it grabbed me to read your story. my favorite qoute was the qoute that explained why the old man needed the boy out on the water with him. i really like the descriptiveness of your story, and i think you should keep writing in that style for the rest of the year.

Anonymous said...

hey juleeee.
great esssay. your thesis was really clear and engaging. my fav quote was “He could feel the steady hard pull of the line and his left hand was cramped” (Pg 58). because it really described all the problems santiago was having. your essay had good wording and was really descriptive. next essay do the same. good jobb jb!

Anonymous said...

julee your essay was really good. your thesis statement was very good and went straight to the point. you were very descriptive. good job.

Anonymous said...

JABBBB.. I really enjoyed your essay, you used very good and important quotes. I think your thesis statement was worked well into your story. The quote that i enjoyed the most was the one about the man needing the boy out in the water with him.BRAVO.

Anonymous said...

JABBBB.. I really enjoyed your essay, you used very good and important quotes. I think your thesis statement was worked well into your story. The quote that i enjoyed the most was the one about the man needing the boy out in the water with him.BRAVO.

Anonymous said...

juleeee, I liked reading your story. Everything was very clear and your thesis statement was good.
All your quotes fit in well and made sense where you put them. My favorite one was the quote about the sharks. It tied nicely into that paragraph. Good jobb.

Anonymous said...

Niceee essay. The thesis was written veryy well. You made the story very interesting by using good words and including important details from the story. Also, you used good quotes to show what yuo were talking about.
niceeeeee
-Raheeeeem

Anonymous said...

juuuleeee. your essay was very goood. your thesis statement really captured my attention. also you picked good qoutes that described exactyle what santiago was going through. you also used great detail in your story